QCOSTARICA – Pilar Cisneros, a renowned journalist, who was the face of television news in Costa Rica for many years until 2013, some calling her “the iron lady of Costa Rica”, spoke out on the current situation facing the country.
Now, an independent journalist, Pilar Cisneros, reappeared with a harsh editorial directed at President Carlos Alvarado, which was originally published by the NEXOPR Agency, cited by CRHoy.com, on October 1.
If you cannot see the video above, see it here.
Here is the translation of her message in English:
We have many reasons to be worried, sad and angry.
Costa Rica is NOT a poor country… it is a country impoverished by some inept or irresponsible politicians. To exacerbate our current crisis to the limit, four governments were enough. Oscar Arias achieved a fiscal surplus in his first two years. But since – according to him – Costa Rica had to be put back on track after the 2008 world crisis, Arias shot up public spending and ended 2010 with the highest fiscal deficit in Latin America: 5.5% of GDP. The number of public employees increased by 20%.
We are heading straight for a debacle, which successive governments of Laura Chinchilla, Luis Guillermo Solís and Carlos Alvarado have only worsened: public spending grew by 87% in the last 12 years.
Today, the average income of the public sector is three times higher than in the private sector. A situation that, according to the OECD, makes Costa Rica one of the countries with the greatest inequality in the world.
Many “public servants” enjoy millionaire luxury pensions, bonuses for arriving early, guaranteed annuities regardless of their performance, and bonuses so juicy that they can exceed their base salary.
And in exchange for what? I ask you looking into your eyes, do you receive an excellent public service? Or even worthy? Do you feel like bureaucrats and institutions help you, make things easier for you, or rather make life difficult for you with endless paperwork, tax on taxes, and mindless requirements?
Politicians allocate multi-million dollar budgets, but they do not demand quality. Do we really need 320 public institutions? Does RECOPE need 1,700 employees even though it has not refined a drop of oil for 9 years? Why, do we still invest 2.8% of GDP to combat poverty, we are not able to reduce it? Where is our money going?
As experts point out, to solve the problem you have to do two things: collect taxes and reduce expenses.
But when I speak of collecting taxes I do not necessarily mean new taxes: I mean that NO GOVERNMENT has made a real commitment to collect them. Our Ministry of Finance is a pity: it has more than 50 obsolete computer systems, and few auditors to control the big evaders, or those who, for decades, have avoided (paying) their taxes. How convenient, no? Why is it that governments do not invest in an institution that could generate billions for their coffers? Could it be that they do not want to harm their great friends, the untouchables?
In the same way, they turn their conspiratorial gaze the other way when it is asked to tax multimillionaire cooperatives, or to review the 192 laws that exempt a series of powerful organized groups from paying taxes. Only removing these exemptions, which are equivalent to 5.57% of GDP, would allow us to cover our fiscal deficit.
And when it comes to lowering spending, the rulers listen … but they don’t act. This Legislative Assembly, one of the best in recent decades, has asked the President of the Republic, time and again, a serious plan to reduce spending.
But no, the Executive’s response is basically a new plan to continue hitting those who produce and employ without reason. Inexplicably, it continues to protect the bureaucratic caste and the evaders who suck the blood of the people at such a rate that they are ruining our economy.
The only plan of the Executive is to go into more and more debt, although almost half of the budget is only to pay debts. Believe me, the US$1.75 billion dollars that an agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) would lend us will disappear very quickly and we will be, more indebted than ever, to see how we escape from the abyss.
Let’s not blame the disaster on COVID. The damn virus only exacerbated and highlighted the economic disaster that we had already been cultivating. And it left one in four Costa Ricans unemployed.
The President of the Republic labels those who do not support new taxes as irresponsible. Those of us who pay them are captive and will continue to pay current taxes and those that will surely come. But it is also very irresponsible to continue paying immoral luxury pensions, it is irresponsible not to collect taxes properly, it is irresponsible not to close obsolete and outdated institutions, it is irresponsible to have 260 salary bonuses in the public sector, it is irresponsible not to fight smuggling head on, it is irresponsible to continue paying millions of dollars in public rents, it is irresponsible to continue supporting an elephant-like state apparatus that we CANNOT PAY for. It is irresponsible to say that the new taxes will be enough to overcome our crisis.
We the citizens, Mr. President, have done a lot on our part. And we will continue to do so to get out of the abyss. But you, too, and this legislative assembly have to do your job together: empower the Ministry of Finance to collect taxes well. Chase the evaders. Share the sacrifice equally: public and private sectors are not enemies, they are a complement to move the country forward. Remove exemptions from anyone who is not essential. Reduce and improve the efficiency of the state apparatus. Demand good performance for good pay. Simplify procedures. Take out pluses (bonuses). Shake hands with entrepreneurs who can create wealth and employment again.
And if the Executive is not able to point out the route, Congress must demand it. Several economists have suggested much more balanced proposals, than an 80% new taxes and only a 20% reduction in spending as this government intends. Listen to them. Consider it. A balanced plan will reduce people’s frustration and hopelessness.
We all want to save Costa Rica. We all want to get jobs back. We all want a better country for our children and grandchildren, Mr. President. Yes, but you and the legislators have to exercise your power so that the weight of the crisis is equally distributed on everyone’s shoulders. It is your duty and it is our right.
You and this legislature can go down in history as true patriots if you do what you must to curb unsustainable spending. Otherwise, you will be remembered as the ones who gave us the last push into the abyss.
I insist: Costa Rica is not a poor country… it is a country impoverished by the rulers who did not measure up to manage everyone’s resources well.
Do not waste the last breath that we may have left to recover our beloved country.
Pilar Cisneros
