Friday, 25 September 2020

Costly Fines Insufficient To Lower Deaths On Costa Rica’s Roads

El desconocimiento en aspectos técnicos de señalización genera acciones como adelantamientos indebidos, que enlutan los hogares de muchos costarricenes. En el 2014 este accidente en la ruta San José - Caldera, dejó tres fallecidos y un herido grave. | ARCHIVO/ALONSO TENORIO
Scenes like the 2104 accident on the Ruta 27 (San Jose – Caldera) that left three dead are common on Costa Rica’s roads. Fines and even the threat of jail for drinking and driving and excessive speeding have not had effect on reducing the carnage. Photo Alnso Tenorio, La Nacion

QCOSTARICA – Improper passing, speeding and driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs continue to be the main cause of fatal traffic accidents in Costa Rica.

What is clear to authorities is that the severe fines introduced in the reforms of the Ley de Transito (Traffic Act) of 2010 and 2012 have had little effect in changing the behaviour of drivers on Costa Rica’s roads.

The high fines set by Legislators in the first reform of the Traffic Act were deemed “disproportionate” by  Constitutional Court, reduced to the current fines.

- paying the bills -

For example, driving under the influence comes with a fine of ¢280.000 colones, and even a criminal penalty (with jail time) for a higher degree of intoxication, but it has not reduced the driving and driving problem.

Before the reforms, a typical fine for speeding, for example, was ¢5.0000. Now, although the fine is ten, fifteen or twenty times or more, and even jail for driving at speeds of 150 km/h or higher, it has had no effect on drivers using Costa Rica’s poorly designed and maintained roads as a superhighway.

Although they are called “autopistas”, there are no highways in Costa Rica, only “carreteras” (roads).

“The culture remained the same; the population was scared for only a few months,” said Jorge Ruiz Ramos, head of the Division of Forensic Engineering of the Organismo de Investigación Judicial (OIJ).

In 2013, Judicial officials investigated 124 road deaths. In 2014, the number was 140.

- paying the bills -

For the period of January 1 to December 17, 2015 the Policia de Transito (traffic police) attended to 376 deaths on the roads (from all types of traffic mishaps). That is  more than one person, on average, dying on the roads daily.

Sonia Monge, deputy director of the Policia de Transito, expressed a urgent appeal to values and conscience of all, not just the drivers.

One of major issues pointed out by the official is missing resources. The Policia de Transito is an effective force of only 763 officials patrolling the entire country. At least another 1.100 are needed to efficiently punish imprudent drivers on the roads, stress traffic authorities,

But the money is nowhere in sight.

And cbecause of this, although there are severe penalties in place, drivers feel they will not penalized for the lack of police on the roads. And they are not wrong. This leads to impunity.

A source close to the Q verified that at night only a handful off traffic officials are on duty, mainly to attend to accidents and other emergencies. On long weekends, for example,  manpower is shifted to have a large police presence during peak times.

- paying the bills --

That means, there are no active patrols at night and other non-peak gtimes. Traffic police spot checks (operativos in Spanish) are infrequent and with the aid of the social networks, they are immediately known. Spot checks by the Fuerza Publica (police), who are empowered to take off the roads drivers under the influence (or driving without license, not having vehicle registration, etc. etc.) are also infrequent.

Driver education is seriously lacking.

William Serrano, judge in the Tribunal Penal de San José is in agreement. Serrano told La Nacion, “negligence and incompetence” mainly of men between 18 and 25 years of age are the cause of most fatal traffic accidents.

Serrano added that the law punishes from six months to eight years in prison for causing a death on the road, but many are resolved through reconciliation through insurance (paying the victim’s family) which leads to few convictions.

"Rico" is the crazy mind behind the Q media websites, a series of online magazines where everything is Q! In these times of new normal, stay at home. Stay safe. Stay healthy.

Related Articles

Blame the drivers: It’s not the posts, but the lack of road safety education

(QCOSTARICA) The installment of the flexible delineator folding posts on the...

Ministry of Transport extends grace for August Riteve inspection

(QCOSTARICA) It's almost the end of August and for owners of...


COVID-19 has sent 5,000 people to hospital in Costa Rica

(QCOSTARICA) Almost 5,000 people in Costa Rica have occupied hospital beds due to COVID-19, reveals the Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social (CCSS). According to data...

12 years in jail for minor for participating in murder of Karolay Serrano

(QCOSTARICA) The cry for justice for the murder of Karolay Serrano Cordero, 26, was heard Monday afternoon, September 21, in the courts of Heredia,...

CNE reveals how the money from the traffic fines is used

(QCOSTARICA) Applauded by some and rejected by others, the sanitary vehicle restriction is one of the most controversial measures that emerged as a strategy...

Chirripó Park once again welcomes tourists in search of fresh air and cleansing the mind

(QCOSTARICA) Starting in October, the Chirripó National Park will once again receive tourists who await landscapes of starry skies, silent mountain sunrises and fresh...

Covid-19 infection rate generally low in Costa Rica, but increases in coastal sites

(QCOSTARICA) The contagion rate of covid-19 in Costa Rica decreased slightly in the last week. However, it is worrisome that coastal areas, with an...

First electric buses will hit the road in November

(QCOSTARICA) The first three electric buses that will serve the country have already arrived and starting in November will begin service on three routes...

Let's Keep This Going!

To be updated with all the latest news and information about Costa Rica and Latin America.

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.