Monday 14 June 2021

Investors Slam Costa Rica’s Claims In $95M Real Estate Row

Q COSTA RICA (by NatalieOlivo, Law360) U.S. investors who claim Costa Rica owes them more than us$95 million for shutting down their beachfront villa project have reiterated before a World Bank tribunal their contention that the Central American nation has failed to back up allegations the project involved construction on protected wetlands, in a letter obtained by Law360 on Thursday.

In the unpublished letter to the tribunal obtained by Law360, the investors again argued that Costa Rica has failed to support its allegations that the properties, referred to as the Las Olas project, contain protected wetlands that required a halt on construction. The investors, who have said the wetland claim was “unfounded and arbitrary,” are seeking US$95.4 million for the nixed project.

“The Las Olas project was fully, and legally, permitted by the appropriate government agencies,” David Aven, one of the investors, told Law360 on Thursday. “It was then shut down, nine months into infrastructure construction, based upon a false claim of wetlands.”

- Advertisement -

The letter, which is dated April 26, was submitted to the tribunal shortly before the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes on Tuesday republished the investors’ 300-plus-page brief. In that filing, the investors said that a local municipality’s work on the project site undermines the country’s argument regarding the wetlands.

More: Costa Rica Says Default Against It Should Be Vacated

According to the brief, which was submitted March 13 and first publicly filed on April 20, the investors said they had recently learned that the Costa Rican Ministry of Transport and Public Works, or MOPT, is carrying out work to replace a sewage system on the Las Olas project site where the purported wetlands are located. When the investors’ counsel asked Costa Rica if it had conducted environmental assessments, the country cited an exception for works involving street repairs.

But Costa Rica can’t have it both ways, the investors said. Either the property near the MOPT works is a wetland and requires an environmental assessment, or — as the investors, their environmental expert witnesses and others have maintained all along — it is not a wetland, according to the brief.

- Advertisement -

Costa Rica has claimed that the investors, who also allege that the country brought baseless criminal charges against them for building on protected lands, deliberately misled government authorities on the environmental impact of their project and undertook work without the proper permits, displaying a “brazen disregard” for Costa Rican law and environmental standards.

But during a February hearing, the transcript of which the ICSID released the following month, the investors questioned why the Central American nation failed to produce any witnesses from the country’s environmental authority, the Ministry of Environment and Energy’s National Environmental Technical Secretariat, or SETENA.

Aven told Law360 that he had raised this issue during his cross-examination in a December hearing as well, when he asked the tribunal where his accusers were.

“Why isn’t someone at this hearing from SETENA to tell the panel directly that I duped them?” Aven asked. “Costa Rica’s entire case was built on allegations, assertions and hearsay that the government continually tried to advance as evidence.”

Costa Rica, meanwhile, reiterated during the December hearing, also publicized by the ICSID in March, its argument that the reality of the investors’ situation is much different than the picture they’ve painted. The investors made unlawful misrepresentations on the conditions of the land, misleading Costa Rican authorities into condoning their false environmental assessments and causing those authorities to issue unlawful permits, Herbert Smith Freehills LLP partner Christian Leathley, who is representing Costa Rica, argued.

They were also able to evade critically important environmental controls by unlawfully fragmenting the land, he said.

- Advertisement -

The investors filed a notice of arbitration in January 2014, arguing that they obtained all of the necessary permits for building luxury beachfront villas, midrange townhouses, smaller villas and a beach club for the Las Olas project. They claim that Costa Rica halted construction following an “unfounded and arbitrary” determination that the property had wetlands and a forest. In reality, the investors said, the stop-work order was based on their failure to pay a $200,000 bribe to a government official.

The country then brought criminal charges against them as a form of intimidation, the investors said.

The country’s Ministry of Foreign Trade shot back last year, telling the ICSID tribunal that the investors had based their arguments against the country on a serious misinterpretation of Costa Rican environmental law and drawn warped conclusions from a blatant misrepresentation of facts.

Counsel for Costa Rica and the investors declined on Thursday to comment. The investors are represented by Vinson & Elkins LLP and Todd Weiler.

Article originally appeared on -Legal News and Analysis.

- Advertisement -

We strive for accuracy in its reports. But if you see something that doesn’t look right, send us an email. The Q reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it’s accuracy.

"Rico" is the crazy mind behind the Q media websites, a series of online magazines where everything is Q! In these times of new normal, stay at home. Stay safe. Stay healthy.

Related Articles

Simple to request certification of vaccines against covid-19 applied in Costa Rica and abroad

QCOSTARICA - The Ministry of Health issued a new guideline on...

The US improves travel alerts for Central America; Not Costa Rica and Nicaragua

QCOSTARICA - The United States has eased travel advisories for most...


Will President Alvarado be vaccinated against Covid-19 soon?

QCOSTARICA - Costa Rican President Carlos Alvarado is just another citizen when it comes to covid-19 vaccination, given his young age and good health,...

Today’s Covid News: A slight drop in new cases and deaths is seen

QCOSTARICA - Faced with wasting a vaccine dose when people in the priority groups scheduled do not show up, and a substitute cannot be...

Should the vaccination against covid-19 be opened?

QCOSTARICA - Six months after the start of vaccination against covid-19, will it be time to open the campaign to those who want to...

Today’s Vehicle Restriction: June 12, “ODDS”

Today, Saturday, June 12, only ODDS can circulate. The measure is countrywide and applied between 5:00 am and 9:00 pm, save for those under the...

Central America is back in the news for the wrong reasons, Costa Rica is once again the exception

QCOSTARICA - Osta Rica has been the epicenter of regional diplomacy in recent days. The successive visits of the Secretary of State of the...

Figueres wins the PLN presidential nomination

QCOSTARICA - Former president, José María Figueres Olsen (1994-1998), on Sunday, became this Sunday the presidential candidate of the Partido Liberación Nacional (PLN) for...

Nicaragua government assures that detainees violated one of the Ten Commandments

TODAY NICARAGUA – The vice president of Nicaragua and First Lady, Rosario Murillo, assured that those who feel persecuted are for the crimes they...

Carlos Alvarado describes calls reprehensible the persecution of Ortega against opponents in Nicaragua

QCOSTARICA - The President of Costa Rica, Carlos Alvarado, described the persecution of Nicaragua President Daniel Ortega against opponents as reprehensible after the government...

Europe opens the doors to tourism, these are the requirements

Q TRAVEL - Europe opened the doors to tourism. While worldwide vaccination against covid-19 advances above the levels of each country, the restrictions are...


Get our daily newsletter with the latest posts directly in your mailbox. Click on the subscribe and fill out the form. It's that simple!

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.