Thursday, 4 June 2020

Jail For Killing A Bird or A Fish? Constitutional Court Says It’s Irrational!

If the proposed animal welfare bill is approved in its current text, a person could go to jail for up to 2 years for abuse of a frog or killing a goldfish

Q COSTA RICA – For the second time, the Constitutional Court or Sala IV found problems of constitutionality in the Animal Welfare bill, a piece of legislation that seeks to get tough on animal abuse.

On Wednesday, by a majority, the magistrates declared ‘irrational’ the decision of legislators to impose fines and jail sentences on those who kill or harm “non-human mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, fish and octopods.”

The magistrates considered that such a broad definition violated the principles of minimum intervention, reasonableness and proportionality.

- paying the bills -

The original draft of the bill only mentioned the term “animals”. In October last the Sala IV told legislators that the definition was too broad.

In November, the bill was amended to change the word “animals” to “nonhuman mammal, bird, reptile, amphibian, fish and octopus capable of feeling pain.”

Thus, if the law were approved as it reads, a person could go to prison for up to 2 years for killing, say a goldfish or a frog.

Not Binding. The ‘observation’ of the Constitutional Court is not binding on legislators, that means the bill could be approved as it is. However, if the bill is approved without changes, at some point someone could challenge it before the Sala IV and could bring that part of the legislation down.

The long road. The Animal Welfare bill was approved in first debate in July 2016. In September the Sala IV deemed “disproportional” the prison sentence of up to three years for hurting or killing an animal, in addition to the monetary fine of up to two base salaries (¢840,000 colones or US$1,500 dollars) for anyone found guilty of animal cruelty, that included the promotion of animal fights, breeding or training an animal to be more aggressive.

- paying the bills -

The amended text, among other changes, dropped the fine to a maximum of ¢212,000 colones and the prison term to a max. of 2 years.

The Constitutional Court also objected to the proposal of fines for animal neglect, that included keeping an animal tied up, intentionally provoking pain and not providing medical treatment.

Although the Constitutional Court considers it excessive to apply protection on such a wide range of animals, it stressed the importance of legislation in this regard.

What’s next? Following the Sala IV review, the bill returns to legislative committee for discussion before it can be presented to the full Legislative Assembly for second and final debate.

Source: La Nacion, with editing by the Q.

"Rico" is the crazy mind behind the Q media websites, a series of online magazines where everything is Q! In these times of new normal, stay at home. Stay safe. Stay healthy.

Related Articles

‘I Declare You Wife and Wife’: Costa Rica Celebrates Its First Equality Marriage

At 0:08 on May 26, 2020, Alexandra Quirós Castillo, 29, and...

Two women will be the first to marry in Costa Rica on May 26

(QCOSTARICA) Same-sex couples in Costa Rica will be able to marry...


Costa Rica President Carlos Alvarado interviewed on BBC

Costa Rica President Carlos Alvarado discusses the containment of the Corona Virus and how it will NOT derail our goals to battle climate change. The...

Rainy Season in Cuba Means Building Collapses in Havana

HAVANA TIMES – The rainy season in Cuba begins and with it the partial and total building collapses. Central Havana and Old Havana are...

Where is this bus going?

Opposition legislators demand of the new Minister of Finance a "route map"!

Nicaragua-Costa Rica bus routes may only carry documented passengers

(QCOSTARICA) Bus companies that transport passengers between Nicaragua and Costa Rica (and vice versa) must request from passengers the cedula (identity card), residency document...

Johnny Araya wants to connect the GAM electric train with a tram for San José

(QCOSTARICA) One day, possibly in the very near future, Costa Rica, at least in the Greater Metropolitan Area (GAM), could have a modern public...

Security Minister wanting a border wall? WTF?

(RICO'S DIGEST) - I couldn't believe what I was hearing the other day watching the live press conference from Casa Presidencial on the coronavirus...

Let's Keep This Going!

To be updated with all the latest news and information about Costa Rica and Latin America.