Tuesday, 4 August 2020

Costa Rica Criminal Court Judges Required To Visit Inmates They Sentenced To Preventive Detention

Overcrowding is typical in Costa Rica's jails. In the case of San Sebastian, in San José, there are 1.140 prisoners in the space designed for 600. Photo: Marcelo Bertozzi, La Nacion
Overcrowding is typical in Costa Rica’s jails. In the case of San Sebastian, in San José, there are 1.140 prisoners in the space designed for 600. Photo: Marcelo Bertozzi, La Nacion

QCOSTARICA — Sleeping on the floor, having to buy your own mat, braving the cold of night and overcrowding is daily life in Costa Rica’s jails, a fact that is now being seen first hand and reported on by the same judges responsible for ordering the incarceration of the many in the jail system.

“The defendant says he braves the cold of night, therefore, gets a cold continuously. He paid ¢4.000 colones for mat and sleeps on the floor, while suffering because his two children depend on him financially,” are the notes of a Puriscal criminal court judge of his visit of a suspect he ordered to preventive detention (remand) in the San Sebastian jail in San José. The visit was on September 26.

The judge, whose identity is being withheld, noted “overcrowding is evident; the heat, unbearable.” In this case, the judge noted that the prisoner is being held in a cell that is meant house 30, but in reality holds 52.

- paying the bills -

The visit by the judge to the jail is due to a regulation of last July 28 by the Corte Plena (Superior Court), requiring criminal court judges who hand down preventive detention sentences, to visit every three months, those they incarcerated. At the end of September there were 2.894 such prisoners in the system.

The requirement of the Superior Court is for criminal court judges to check whether the conditions of detention respect fundamental rights and provide a quarterly report.

But not all is going as the Superior Court had expected.

Up to October, only seven judges have obeyed the provision. The seven work in the criminal courts of Puriscal, Liberia, Buenos Aires, the Juzgado Penal Juvenil de Cañas and the Tribunales de Juicio de San Carlos and Puntarenas. The visits were to the  San Sebastián, La Marina, Zurquí, Liberia, El Roble and Pérez Zeledón jails, between September and October.

The Criminal Court of San Carlos submitted to the Superior Court its concerns of inmates very time a judge made a visit and their condition does not improve.

- paying the bills -

But the Superior Court said that visit requirement will be maintained.

Judge Patricia Solano of the Tribunal de Juicio de San José, one of several judges interviewed by La Nacion, argues that close contact with a suspect in prison threatens the purity of the process. She asks rhetorically, what would a victim of rape feel to learn that the judge is direct contact with the suspect?

For her, the visits can lead to either sympathy or antipathy, which affects objectivity. She added that the judges cannot order Adaptación Social (state prison management) how to manage a prison.

Juan Carlos Pérez, coordinator of the San José court office, noted that prisoner rights groups and the Defensoría de los Habitantes (Ombudsman) review prison conditions.

The judges, with the support of the Asociación Costarricense de la Judicatura (Acojud) – Costa Rican Association of the Judiciary, has asked the Superior Court to suspend the visits.

In Costa Rica, preventive detention is used by the courts to order a person to “preventive” imprisonment of 12 months if the person is considered a “flight risk”, but if the case is declared “complex”, it can be increased to up to three years and a half of imprisonment without conviction, or even more in some cases, while the case is under investigation. In preventive detnetion, there are no charges filed and no trial date set.

- paying the bills --


"Rico" is the crazy mind behind the Q media websites, a series of online magazines where everything is Q! In these times of new normal, stay at home. Stay safe. Stay healthy.

Related Articles

Marchamo is a fair tax and “it makes no sense” to reduce it, says Minister of Finance

(QCOSTARICA) The Marchamo, the vehicular right to circulate, "is a fair...

No “Zapote Fair”, “Tope” & “Carnaval” this year

(QCOSTARICA) In the 50 years of tradition, this 2020 will be...


Non-Canadian, EU or UK citizens with new entry rules for Costa Rica

(QCOSTARICA) Travelers who are not citizens of countries authorized to fly to Costa Rica for now, such as U.S. citizens, will be able to...

COVID-19 in Costa Rica: Total infections more than 17,000; CNE to warms communities approaching orange alert

(QCOSTARICA) With 490 new cases of COVID-19 this Thursday, the cumulative total reached 17,290 cases, the Ministry of Health reported. The figure comes two days...

Six people arrested for obstructing ruta 27 this Friday morning

(QCOSTARICA) Six people were arrested for blocking passage on the ruta 27, at the Santa Ana intersection, this Friday morning. The arrests were made by...

Italian woman dies touching electrical cable in Puerto Viejo

A 54-year-old Italian woman died on Wednesday after suffering an electric shock in Puerto Viejo de Talamanca, Limón. The victim was identified as...

Mobile hospital carries out COVID-19 tests to Nicaraguans stranded at border

(QCOSTARICA) The Arias Foundation for Peace reported that COVID tests for Nicaraguans stranded on the northern border began today, Friday, July 31, after obtaining...

No “Zapote Fair”, “Tope” & “Carnaval” this year

(QCOSTARICA) In the 50 years of tradition, this 2020 will be the second time the year-end celebrations will be canceled: the first time in...

Let's Keep This Going!

To be updated with all the latest news and information about Costa Rica and Latin America.