Q COSTA RICA —Costa Rica’s Universidad Nacional(UNA)—National University—has urged lawmakers to shelve a proposed free trade agreement with Israel, arguing that its limited economic benefits do not outweigh concerns about human rights, the environment and Costa Rica’s obligations under international law.
UNA’s University Council adopted the position on October 29 in response to a request for its assessment from a congressional committee. The bill to approve the agreement is before the Legislative Assembly as file 25.542. UNA’s recommendation is not a legislative decision, but it adds to opposition from another public university: the University of Costa Rica’s (UCR) University Council also recommended against approval in October.
The university questioned how much Costa Rica stands to gain. Figures included in its assessment put 2025 exports to Israel at US$25.9 million and imports from Israel at US$35.8 million—together, about 0.2% of Costa Rica’s total trade.
UNA also argued that tariff concessions would not necessarily translate into equal opportunities for both countries. Israel would immediately remove tariffs on 90.7% of its tariff lines, compared with 82.2% for Costa Rica, but UNA said Israeli protections remain concentrated in primary agriculture and fresh foods, where Costa Rican producers have export potential.
Costa Rica, meanwhile, would grant early tariff benefits to industrial and technology products in which Israel is commercially strong.
A sharper concern involves the agreement’s definition of Israeli territory.
UNA said Article 1.6 refers to territory where Israeli customs laws apply without expressly drawing a geographic boundary. In the university’s view, that wording “could” allow goods made or processed in Israeli settlements in occupied Palestinian territory to receive preferential treatment.
UNA cited a UN Security Council resolution and a 2024 advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in support of its concern about distinguishing Israeli territory from occupied Palestinian territory. The university did not establish that such goods have already received benefits under the proposed deal.
UNA also pointed to the absence of dedicated human-rights and environmental chapters, impact-assessment procedures and mechanisms for public participation. Its environmental human-rights clinic recommended against approving the bill in its current form and called for stronger checks on product origins, broader impact assessments and continuing social and environmental oversight.
The University Council separately raised concerns about provisions involving digital services and data, as well as potential tariff benefits for imports including arms, ammunition and hazardous substances or waste.
The legislative question is now about more than market access.
UNA is asking lawmakers to weigh a small existing trade relationship against the legal, diplomatic and ethical risks it identifies. Costa Rica’s government has presented the agreement as a way to expand commercial and cooperative opportunities in fields including cybersecurity, precision agriculture and medical technology.
But on November 13 it withdrew the bill from the agenda for extraordinary legislative sessions so new foreign-affairs and trade officials could review it, Delfino.cr reported, citing Noticias Monumental.
That withdrawal gives the government time to reassess the proposal; it does not, by itself, amount to the permanent shelving UNA has requested.
Discover more from Q COSTA RICA
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

