Tuesday 13 April 2021

Nicaragua’s Unfinished Revolution Takes A New Turn

(Bloomberg) Whether brandishing a Kalashnikov or a stacked court, Nicaragua’s President Daniel Ortega has proven especially resilient. The onetime guerrilla insurgent turned autocrat has endured turmoil, outsmarted opponents and coopted rivals to lock down four presidential mandates spread out across 38 years, marshal economic growth and outlast authoritarian peers.

If Sandino could see them now. Photographer: AFP Contributor/AFP

So when protests exploded in the streets of Managua and other cities earlier this month, leaving at least 38 dead and provoking calls for Ortega’s ouster, that idyll was shattered. The breadth and speed of unrest are new in Nicaragua and may prove to be an inflection point, if not a terminus, for one of Latin American autocracy’s most successful brands.

The immediate trigger was a ham-fisted social security reform, announced earlier this month by decree, and then revoked just as abruptly on April 22 after a week of riots.

- Advertisement -

On the surface, the proposal seemed reasonable enough. Like most of its neighbors, Nicaragua spends too much on pensions for a society that is graying fast even as its taxable working age population shrinks. Nicaragua’s fertility rate fell by more than half, from 5 children per woman in 1990 to 2.3 in 2015, while life expectancy rose 13 years to age 75 in the same period, according to a report by the International Monetary Fund.

That’s hardly the hemisphere’s worst case. But what’s worrisome – and galling – for one of Central America’s poorest nations is that the Ortega government has made the vexing demographics more dangerous through doubtful administration and murky deals.

After a partial makeover in 2006, Nicaragua ran a surplus in social security for the next six years. Thrift ended, however, in 2013, when Ortega’s government began investing in questionable real estate deals and subsidized mortgages. Hence the IMF’s warning last year that social security was on track to “run out of liquid reserves by 2019” and that “the authorities should act quickly to avoid a costly bailout of the system.”

After punting reforms for years, Ortega surprised his compatriots with a hasty decree on April 16, ordering an increase in social security taxes and a cut in benefits, and sparked a revolt. “When people found they would be paying more and getting less for it, they were outraged,” Manuel Orozco, an economist at the Inter-American Dialogue told me.

- Advertisement -

For Nicaraguans, that was just the latest in a string of Ortega’s offenses. Resentment surged last year when the U.S. Treasury charged Nicaraguan supreme electoral council president Roberto Rivas with amassing considerable personal wealth while on the government payroll. Ortega’s riposte? He not only protected Rivas but kept him on the job as the electoral council sponsored a sweeping, executive-friendly reform of electoral laws, over protests by citizen groups and opposition lawmakers.

The mood darkened last month when the government announced it had asked the legislature to “review the use of social networks,” which was widely seen as code for censorship, drawing an immediate retort from Nicaraguan non-government organizations and the Catholic Church.

Then came the botched response to a wildfire – including an official decision to turn away a team of Costa Rican firefighters who’d volunteered to help – which destroyed 7,000 hectares of an important bio-reserve and covered several forest communities in a pall of smoke and ash. Nicaragua belatedly accepted help from a Mexican fire brigade.

“Ortega had always been seen as a kind of master player, but absolute rulers have a blind spot,” said Orozco. “What he didn’t realize is that the anger against his government had been growing.”

Now Nicaraguans may have found opportunity in Ortega’s debacle, including some unlikely apostates. One of the casualties of the public backlash over pensions could be the longtime government pact with the country’s private sector: In return for executives’ support for his policies – and their complicit silence on its authoritarian excesses – Ortega had allowed companies to prosper.

That alliance has worked reasonably well for both sides, not least because of the blessings businesses have reaped on Ortega’s watch, including annual corporate tax breaks worth 6 percent of gross domestic product. Not coincidentally, says the IMF, those perks have added to Nicaragua’s worsening fiscal woes.

- Advertisement -

Yet Ortega’s fiat has not always been good for business. In a 2015 survey, 47 percent of company executives said they felt their property rights were not guaranteed by law and 50 percent said mechanisms for settling disputes were inefficient.

Finally, the moguls appear to be stirring. The leading business chamber, known by its acronym COSEP, representing companies that kick in around half of Nicaraguan GDP, has pointedly criticized the heavy-handed official response to protests and called for dialogue – not a favorite in the Sandinista playbook.

Talk alone is unlikely to curb the Nicaraguan government’s authoritarian instincts. But clearly the unofficial pact of indulgences as well as the private sector’s complicit silence must end.

Thanks to years of centralizing power, Ortega has all but defenestrated the country’s political opposition. Students and civil society groups have stepped up in the wake of the disastrous pension reform plan. Will the private sector do its part? “The business community is one of the most legitimate social forces in the country,” said Orozco. “That makes them political players, whether they like it or not.”

The precedent exits. Almost 40 year ago, business leaders joined forces with the political opposition and labor unions, funding three political strikes that helped drive then-Nicaraguan dictator Gen. Anastasio Somoza from power. That was the precursor of COSEP’s subsequent complicated alliance with the Sandinistas. Now, surely, it’s time for that tryst to end.

Article by Mac Margolis first appeared on Bloomberg View. Read the original.

Article originally appeared on Today Nicaragua and is republished here with permission.

- Advertisement -

We strive for accuracy in its reports. But if you see something that doesn’t look right, send us an email. The Q reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it’s accuracy.

Q24N is an aggregator of news for Latin America. Reports from Mexico to the tip of Chile and Caribbean are sourced for our readers to find all their Latin America news in one place.

Related Articles

Daniel Ortega Among “Worst Leaders” During the Pandemic

TODAY NICARAGUA – Calling people into the streets for a festive...


How Costa Ricans Are Curbing Their Lockdown Boredom?

Maybe you hate lockdowns, and we don’t blame you. They are definitely necessary, as there are plenty of advantages. Besides the health benefits of...

Couple used fast food delivery services to hide sales of marijuana pastries

HQ - A couple was arrested on suspicion of using fast food delivery services to deliver marijuana pastries sold in the Greater Metropolitan Area...

What is mRNA? The messenger molecule that’s been in every living cell for billions of years is the key ingredient in some COVID-19 vaccines

One surprising star of the coronavirus pandemic response has been the molecule called mRNA. It’s the key ingredient in the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19...

India Overtakes Brazil as Second Worst-Hit Country by COVID-19

Q24N - The death toll from the coronavirus infection in the world has topped 2.93 million; over 136 million cases of the infection have...

“Nicaragua is not a Republic, it is a 16th century monarchy”

TODAY NICARAGUA – If he wins the presidency of Nicaragua, the first international trip that presidential candidate Arturo Cruz would make would be to...

Bolsonaro’s ‘genocidal’ Covid response has led to Brazilian catastrophe, Dilma Rousseff says

Q REPORTS (TheGuardian) Jair Bolsonaro’s perverse and “genocidal” response to one of the world’s deadliest Covid outbreaks has left Brazil “adrift on an ocean...

Spike in covid-19 cases could bring back the “hammer”

QCOSTARICA - The spike in cases of covid-19 in recent days set off the alarms and has the authorities analyzing the possibility of bringing...

Netflix to premiere Attenborough documentary filmed in Costa Rica

TODAY COSTA RICA - Neither the coronavirus nor the global confinement managed to prevent the renowned naturalist, Sir David Attenborough, from filming in our...

Beginning of the week will be loaded with afternoon rains, says weather service

QCOSTARICA - Today, Monday, April 12, rains accompanied by a thunderstorm are expected during the afternoon, no different than the rains pouring down over...


Get our daily newsletter with the latest posts directly in your mailbox. Click on the subscribe and fill out the form. It's that simple!

Article originally appeared on Today Nicaragua and is republished here with permission.

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.