Pilar Cisneros attacks prison inspection, putting victims’ rights at the center of Costa Rica debate

Former legislator criticizes officials for focusing on the rights of criminals rather than that of the victims

Q COSTA RICA — Former legislator and a close ally of Rodrigo Chaves, Pilar Cisneros, has accused two senior officials of paying more attention to prisoners than to victims of crime after they visited the maximum-security prison known as CACCO.

“How long are we going to give hugs to those who shoot us?” Cisneros asked in a Facebook video. Her criticism was directed at Attorney General Carlo Díaz and Ombudswoman Angie Cruickshank, who inspected the prison following complaints of alleged mistreatment and human-rights abuses.

Cisneros’s video featured relatives of crime victims who said they had not received visits or support from the prosecutor’s office or the ombudsman’s office. Their accounts framed her central question: Why, they asked, were senior officials visiting prisoners when victims’ families felt neglected?

The prison visit also drew a response in the legislature. All 31 lawmakers in the governing party bloc, Partido Pueblo Soberano (PPSO), backed a motion censuring Díaz and Cruickshank and urging them to resign.

Díaz and Cruickshank described a different purpose for their visit: hearing directly from prisoners held under maximum-security conditions and examining allegations about their treatment.

Díaz said prisoners had been beaten and that some had been treated improperly when their hair was cut; Cruickshank said her office received complaints of alleged physical assaults and inadequate medical care for people with serious illnesses. She also said the inspection found no mechanism for prisoners to submit complaints to her institution.

Her office would investigate those matters, she said, while reminding prison authorities that retaliation against people who provided information was prohibited. La República

A dispute over attention, not a choice between rights

Cisneros’s argument draws force from a grievance that deserves a direct answer. Families who say they have been left without support should be heard, and public officials should be able to explain what assistance victims can expect.

The prison allegations raise a separate obligation. Inspecting conditions in custody is not the same as excusing the crimes of people held there. Nor does investigating alleged abuse diminish the harm suffered by victims. Cruickshank’s statement explicitly paired security with respect for human rights, rather than treating them as competing aims.

The political argument turns those duties into an either-or choice: attention to prisoners is presented as attention taken away from victims. The more useful test is whether the prosecutor’s office and the ombudsman’s office follow through on both.

That means investigating the complaints from CACCO and giving victims’ families a clear account of the support available to them. On the evidence reported so far, neither concern makes the other disappear.


Discover more from Q COSTA RICA

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

- A word from our sponsors -

spot_img

Latest Stories

- A word from our sponsors -

Most Popular

More stories ...

- A word from our sponsors -

spot_img