Wednesday 5 May 2021

Socialism: The Problem of Venezuela (and Latin America)

The economic, political and social disaster of Venezuela is the result of leading a nation to socialism. There are two ways to achieve this goal: the revolution, proposed by Karl Marx; and the progressivism, introduced by the Fabians—an English school that promotes the transition from capitalism to socialism-through the gradual and reformist effort of democracies.

The recent chaos is the result of increasing socialist policies, especially hyperinflation, combined with declining oil revenues. (Image: EFE)

The failed experiments in the Soviet Union, Communist China, and Cambodia discredited the revolutionary option.

These tragedies caused the deaths of almost 100 million people—more than the combined deaths from the First and Second World Wars. However, instead of rethinking their ideas, theorists and political promoters of socialism sought a new approach based on the seizure of power through democratic means to implement a progressive agenda that lead their nations to the socialist utopia.

- Advertisement -

With this idea, many political movements have been rising in America at the end of the twenty-century, including the democratic socialism, the socialism of the XXI century and, recently, the “millennial” socialism.

The concept of socialism refers to the common ownership of the means of production with the sole purpose of use and not the generation of profits. Nowadays, with some exceptions, there are no totalitarian socialist regimes, but instead, countries lie on a continuous scale that marks in the extremes totalitarian socialism in one side, and anarchist capitalism on the other, depending on the characteristics of their political and economic systems. This distinction, however, is not evident and many analysts argue erroneously about successful and unsuccessful cases of socialism.

For example, some political and economic analysts argue that a number of Latin American countries have embraced socialist projects and, with the exception of Nicaragua and Venezuela, were able to prosper, neglecting that these projects presented some of the chronic symptoms currently exacerbated in Venezuela: corruption, inflation, and uncontrolled public spending.

The increase in commodity prices explains the apparent success of socialism in countries such as Ecuador and Brazil; once this boom ended, the socialist “success” was over. Similarly, despite having nationalized dozens of companies since 2006—at a cost that exceeds 3,5% of GDP—Bolivia is referred as another case of socialist success, in which future potential economic problems might be related to macroeconomic conditions.

From social media
- Advertisement -

However, the expansion in government spending still does not cause devaluation pressures in Bolivia because the Central Bank fixed the exchange rate at the expense of its dollar reserves, which have dropped by almost 50% in the last four years.

But let’s focus this analysis on Venezuela. The Communist Party of Venezuela (PCV), founded in 1931, is the alma mater of Venezuela’s politicians. Over the years, as the leaders abandoned communism and embraced democratic socialism, they create a large number of parties that conform today’s Venezuelan political system. The political discourse of these emerging leaders always reflected the conviction that a capitalist market economy is only a transitory stage towards some form of socialism.

Venezuela is a case study that went from being an economic success to a humanitarian disaster. Since the emergence of the oil industry, around the 1920s, until the late 1950s, Venezuela’s economy was able to combine economic growth with declining poverty rates, making the country a regional center for immigration settlements. In 1975, the socialist democratic government of Carlos Andrés Pérez nationalized the iron and oil industries.

Then, geopolitical events caused the price of oil to increase dramatically, producing excessive revenues that tipped the balance of power in society in favor of the Government. Until 1998, despite the existence of a market economy, government actions aim to reduce economic freedom were widely implemented, including exchange controls, currency devaluation, monetary inflation, price and wage controls, barriers to trade, forced redistribution of wealth, and highly progressive taxes — all these policies accompanied by the typical Third World’s anti-imperialist rhetoric.

The arrival of Hugo Chávez to power, in 1998, exacerbated socialist policies, as the government was devoted to political control.

Starting in 2003, a set of confiscatory laws created political unrest, which resulted in increasing government interventions. Again, with the increase of international oil prices, the government raised public spending, specifically the so-called “social” spending through monetary transfers that appeared to reduce poverty.

- Advertisement -

Within this strategy, the regime increased its power by giving Russia and China blocks of oil reserves in exchange for loans for present consumption, leaving the country as a simple pawn within the global geopolitics. The recent chaos is the result of increasing socialist policies, especially hyperinflation, combined with declining oil revenues.

John M. Keynes wrote that Lenin “declared that the best way to destroy the capitalist system was by corrupting money. Through a process of continuous inflation, governments can confiscate, secretly and stealthily, an important part of the wealth of their citizens.”

After some trips to Venezuela, I witnessed this economic crisis. I was amazed to listen to young professionals argue that Venezuela would never become another Cuba, while supermarkets were empty and their homes lacked toilet paper. Likewise, my colleague Osmel had to move his family to the Dominican Republic as a result, and start a new life as a professor and entrepreneur.

The lesson here is that socialism is no longer revolutionary.

Today, socialism comes in a set of progressive reforms aimed at reducing economic and political liberties, which is not possible without harming minorities. Our conclusion is straightforward.

Yes, socialism was adopted in Venezuela—as well as many countries in Latin America—and socialism is the cause of the current crisis. But, like the devil, the success of socialism is based on its ability to make people believe that it has never been implemented.

Article by Harold Vásquez was first published at Panampost.com. Read the original here.

Harold Vásquez is a research professor of Economics at the Instituto Tecnológico de Santo Domingo (INTEC) and Osmal Brito is a professor of Economics at Pontificia Universidad Católica Madre y Maestra.

Article originally appeared on Today Venezuela and is republished here with permission.

- Advertisement -

FACT CHECK:
We strive for accuracy in its reports. But if you see something that doesn’t look right, send us an email. The Q reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it’s accuracy.

Q24N
Q24N is an aggregator of news for Latin America. Reports from Mexico to the tip of Chile and Caribbean are sourced for our readers to find all their Latin America news in one place.

Related Articles

“There can be no divorce between economy and health”

QCOSTARICA - Following is an opinion piece by Dr. Rodolfo Hernández...

“Nicaragua is not a Republic, it is a 16th century monarchy”

TODAY NICARAGUA – If he wins the presidency of Nicaragua, the...

MOST READ

Entertainment Or Nature. What’s Better In Costa Rica?

Costa Rica is a country filled with beautiful nature, miles of coastline, and even volcanic formations. All these things make it a wonderful place...

Airport Police apprehend American carrying crocodile head

QCOSTARICA - Authorities from the Air Surveillance Service (SVA) - airport police - apprehended an American named Dale, who was in possession of an...

Today’s Covid News: Daily cases of COVID-19 continues to decline; young adults most infected

QCOSTARICA - After breaking all records last week, the number of new daily cases of Covid-19 in Costa Rica continues on the decline, according...

Down to to only 10 beds for ‘very critical’ covid patients

QCOSTARICA - This Monday noon, May 3, the Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social (CSS) reported there were only ten free beds to receive Covid-19...

Costa Rica received the largest to date batch of covid-19 vaccines

QCOSTARICA - A new batch with 124,020 doses of the covid-19 vaccine landed on national soil this Tuesday night, as part of the weekly...

Dra. Daniela Ruiz, the pediatrician and dermatologist who breaks paradigms

TODAY COSTA RICA - Despite the fact that she does not consider herself an influencer, Dr. Daniela Ruiz Guzmán has grown by leaps and...

Swiss City Wants to Send Homeless to Other European Cities

Q REPORTS - Switzerland, a country with the highest density of millionaires, a high density of billionaires, and its economy one of the world's...

Woman who lured men with a motorcycle, drugged and robbed them

QCOSTARICA - A 22-year-old woman with the surname Rivera Cubillo was arrested, suspected of luring men through the internet and then robbing them. She was...

Today’s Covid News: New record of cases broken again, 2,434 in 24 hours

QCOSTARICA - The health emergency due to covid-19 once again breaks records in Costa Rica, this Wednesday the Ministry of Health reported 2,434 new...

WANT TO STAY UP TO DATE WITH THE LATEST!

Get our daily newsletter with the latest posts directly in your mailbox. Click on the subscribe and fill out the form. It's that simple!

Article originally appeared on Today Venezuela and is republished here with permission.

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.