Wednesday, 23 September 2020

What’s behind wealthy Chile’s deadly protests?

The protests began over a planned hike in transport fares last week, but have turned into a movement against Chile's economic model of creeping privatization, low wages and growing inequality.

Less than one month out from the international Asian Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Santiago, the political and social situation in Chile is anything but calm. Protests against a metro fare hike began last Monday, and events since then have accelerated at an alarming speed.

While a metro fare hike sparked the violent demonstrations in Chile, experts say discontent is much deeper and far-reaching.

General discontent turned into banging pots and pans, the destruction of metropolitan train stations and the burning of buses, supermarkets and other buildings in the capital, Santiago.

The protests also quickly spread to other areas of the country.

- paying the bills -

Seven people had died as of Sunday.

The government of President Sebastian Pinera reacted by describing the discontent as the work of criminals and called a state of emergency, including a curfew — measures which have not been seen since the return of democracy in 1990, except in cases of natural catastrophes.

These only worsened the situation, and outrage has not diminished. In and around Santiago, public transport remains largely shut down, flights have been canceled, supermarkets will not open until further notice and classes have been suspended.

State of emergency. Metro stations, buses and businesses were set ablaze as the protests began to turn violent.

“Instead of having empathy, the government has responded with a ‘hard hand’ that denies people’s suffering and their demands for justice,” Jorge Saavedra, a lecturer in Cambridge University’s sociology department, told DW. The expert on Chile said this problem has been going on for some time and is in part responsible for citizens’ discontent. “Ministry declarations that belittle people and their suffering, for example by telling them that long wait times in the public health system are a chance to socialize, show the disdain of a government that does not have the communication competencies to empathize with those who are having a hard time.”

An abused society

- paying the bills -

Pinera said one week ago that Chile was “an oasis” in Latin America. So how should one understand this explosion of dissatisfaction in a country that has healthy macroeconomic indicators and is usually seen as peaceful?

“It is not smart to arrogantly point fingers, especially when there are deep social fractures that haven’t been processed correctly,” Cristobal Bellolio, lawyer and assistant professor of political philosophy at Santiago’s Adolfo Ibanez University, told DW. These fractures have to do with a quality of life that is usually above the means of the people. “Chileans are paying for services that cost more than they can afford,” he explained.

“If you scratch beyond the surface of Chile, there is evidence of enormous social, cultural, economic and political injustice. Its good image stands on weak pillars that are supported, in large part, by the patience of a people who are getting tired of being abused,” Saaverdra said. The rise in metro fares was the drop of water that made the cup overflow in a country where basic services are privatized, social security is precarious and the privileges of certain sectors have angered a large segment of the population that feels shunted aside.

With an APEC summit one month away, Sebastian Pinera’s government faces a tricky situation. Experts say Pinera has not been sympathetic to the discontent of Chileans

“What began as a statement against fare hikes reached its greatest expression when it was presented as a general fatigue over systematic increases to the cost of living,” Bellolio said. He thinks the demands of the citizens could be affected by the vandalism. “Social movements get their demands addressed by authorities insofar as they have the public’s sympathy. And if you burn metro stations, if you burn grocery stores that are sources of employment for those who live nearby, people will get fed up with the protests.”

Authorities do not yet know exactly who is behind the destructive acts. Groups of anarchists and marginalized sectors of society are suspected, although there are some violence-prone individuals or criminals that take advantage of these occasions to commit all sorts of provocations, destroying infrastructure that is essential for a city’s normal functioning.

An absent government

- paying the bills --

All across the media, many people are asking why it took the government so long to react to the situation and why President Pinera has been so absent during the full-blown crisis, with just a short public appearance on Saturday.

Asking for the impossible? This demonstrator is holding a sign that reads “Let’s be realistic, let’s ask for the impossible.”

“I think the government rapidly handed control to the military because it never had control of the situation. What is happening has not been seen for five decades in Chile,” said Saavedra. He sees a difficult road ahead for the government, which has only been in power for 19 months.

“The government has acted in a really clumsy manner; it limited the problem to a question of public order and missed a golden opportunity. And by the time Pinera announced he was freezing the metro rate hike, it was really late,” Bellolio said, describing the government’s actions as incompetent and negligent. “It has been absent, and handing over power to the military is a sign of all this,” he adds.

Can Chile hold the APEC summit amidst all this? Bellolio has his doubts. “We don’t know if this violence is a cathartic expression that will end here or whether there are cells preparing more protests. If the government reacts no, it could have a chance to save the summit.”

Related Articles

COVID-19 was the leading cause of death in hospitals in Costa Rica during August

(QCOSTARICA) Deaths associated with COVID-19 became the leading cause of death...

“They say the taxes are temporary”

The illustration confirms the sentiment of most, not believing that the...


Another narco drone attempts delivery in Alajuela prison

(QCOSTARICA) You have to hand it to the enterprising nature of Criminals who are ncreasingly turning to technology. On Saturday, just as an Amazon or...

COVID-19 Costa Rica: 1,338 new cases for Saturday, Sept 19

(QCOSTARICA) The new norm for daily cases is 1000 plus daily and the number of deaths hovering near 20 almost every day. For Saturday, September...

Banks warn about the proposed temporary tax on financial transactions

The government of Carlos Alvarado is proposing a set of new taxes, that include a temporary tax (4 years) on banking transactions, to obtain...

Doctors took to the streets of San José to give away masks and teach how to use them

(QCOSTARICA) A group of some 15 doctors and helpers gave away masks and taught how to use them correctly to passes by on the...

The death of Dr. Salas’ father comes at a difficult time

RICO'S DIGEST -  I have no doubt that this is a moment of great weight for the majority in Costa Rica who identify with...

This is how the tax on ATM transactions would work

(QCOSTARICA) Costa Rica president Carlos Alvarado on Thursday outlined the proposed new taxes that would be imposed in order to obtain a US$2.25 billion...

Let's Keep This Going!

To be updated with all the latest news and information about Costa Rica and Latin America.

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.