Sunday 11 April 2021

Why is bus service so bad on the Nicoya-San José route?

Alfaro bus company conducted a survey among passengers, whose most frequent complaint was the limited space between the bus seats. Photo by Ariana Crespo
Alfaro bus company conducted a survey among passengers, whose most frequent complaint was the limited space between the bus seats. Photo by Ariana Crespo

by Maria Fernanda Cruz, Vozdeguanacaste.com – As the sky opens up and rain pours down, the roof above my seat on the bus from San José to Nicoya also is raining. Water drips on my head, on my clothes and on my computer as if we were outdoors. I open my umbrella.

“What can we do, go on strike?” a frustrated rider, Marietta Díaz, asks as she waits for the driver to fix yet another problem.

- Advertisement -

But filing formal complaints over these types of problems often entails navigating cumbersome bureaucracy at the Public Transportation Council, or CTP, and the Public Services Regulatory Authority (ARESEP). Worse, official responses to those complaints rarely come in a timely fashion.

When riders like Díaz do follow through with complaints to the CTP, which oversees public transportation contracts, the best outcome they can hope for is a “stern warning” for the company – not a fine.

“The only punishment that exists (from the CTP) is canceling the concession, and that’s only happened once in the country’s history. And that was because the bus caught fire,” said former Transportation Vice Minister Sebastián Urbina, a day before he was dismissed from his post by the president.

denuncia-alfaro-ing

According to Urbina, current regulations do not allow the council to impose sanctions on licensees, apart from cancelling contracts. In order for that to happen, a company must have accumulated at least three complaints from users.

- Advertisement -

The CTP’s board of directors, which renews or cancels concessions, also is composed of the same licensees, such as bus company and taxi owners, relegating them to both judge and jury in disputes.

Meanwhile, the concession holder of the San José-Nicoya route, Transportes Alfaro, insists that its buses receive constant maintenance, although a spokesman acknowledges that some of the buses have problems.

Company spokesman Germán Alfaro said the company’s fleet of buses is replaced every 15 years as required by current legislation, and there is no reason to cancel the company’s contract.

“The bus with the leaks, the Chirriche, was repaired last week. And the driver is monitoring it to make sure there are no new leaks,” Alfaro said.

Taking action

What can consumers do when public transportation providers fail to comply with contract requirements?

Bus riders have two options: Contacting the CTP or ARESEP.

- Advertisement -

Public services Law 7593 defines the right of consumers to file complaints when public services or tariffs are irregular.

Exercising this right, however, can be a significant hassle for consumers, who must first report complaints to the responsible company. If the company fails to respond in 10 business days, the consumer can then go to ARESEP (see infographic).

ARESEP spokeswoman Carolina Mora said only two complaints were filed against the company Alfaro since 2013. In both cases, the company was fined from ₡2 million ($3,700) to ₡8 million ($14,800), the maximum allowed by law. Resolving these types of complaints can take at least six months and up to a year.

Mora said that although public transportation services usually generate constant complaints from users, those complaints rarely reach ARESEP.

“If complaints don’t leave the bus stop, how is ARESEP going to know about bad service?” Mora asked during a recent telephone interview.

Last year, that regulatory agency fined Transportes Alfaro more than ₡5 million ($9,251) due to the “charging of unauthorized fare rates.” It also fined the company Tralapa from Santa Cruz nearly ₡7.4 million ($13,700) for unfair competition and service irregularities.

 

- Advertisement -

FACT CHECK:
We strive for accuracy in its reports. But if you see something that doesn’t look right, send us an email. The Q reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it’s accuracy.

Ricohttp://www.theqmedia.com
"Rico" is the crazy mind behind the Q media websites, a series of online magazines where everything is Q! In these times of new normal, stay at home. Stay safe. Stay healthy.

Related Articles

It wasn’t me… it was the Aresep.

The RECOPE, the Costa Rican refinery that doesn't refine anything, washes...

Super gasoline costs today ¢700!

QCOSTARICA - The dreaded increase has been announced for April. The...

MOST READ

Ex model got tough with follower who wanted to know if she is an escort

Q MAGAZINE - Former model and television presenter Pamela Méndez was clear and direct to a follower who asked her if she was a...

Top 5 SaaS Cloud Apps To Check Out in 2021

The Software as a Service (SaaS) model isn’t something new at all. There are already several years since SaaS began to gain a lot...

Avianca to fly direct San José and Miami starting July 1

QCOSTARICA - Avianca airlines announced that starting next July 1, 2021, it will fly daily non-stop between San José (SJO) and Miami (MIA). The Colombia...

Pharmacies could sell any Covid-19 vaccine authorized by regulatory agencies

QCOSTARICA  - Any vaccine against Covid-19 that has authorization from a regulatory agency recognized by the World Health Organization (WHO) could be sold in...

Brazilian variant of coronavirus detected in Costa Rica

QCOSTARICA - A 28-year-old man from Alajuela and a 32-year-old woman from Heredia are the first two cases of people infected with the SARS-CoV-2...

7 Costa Rican Footballers Making MLS Waves

Costa Rica has a strong history of punching well above its weight when it comes to producing top quality footballing talent. This is in...

Fake massage parlor was used for sexual services in Guadalupe

HQ - A 42-year-old woman, a Venezuelan national identified by her last name Padilla Mujica, was detained by agents of the Organismo de Investigación...

Brazilian Prostitutes ‘Priority Group’ COVID Vaccination

Q24N - Prostitutes in the Brazilian city of Belo Horizonte have gone on a week-long strike, urging the government to give them prioritized COVID...

Minister of Health will criminally denounce doctors who refuse to be vaccinated

QCOSTARICA - The Minister of Health, Daniel Salas, said on Tuesday during the press conference from Casa Presidencial, he will go to court to...

WANT TO STAY UP TO DATE WITH THE LATEST!

Get our daily newsletter with the latest posts directly in your mailbox. Click on the subscribe and fill out the form. It's that simple!

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.