Q COSTA RICA — Nine months after American surfer Kurt Van Dyke was found dead in his Costa Rican home, investigators have arrested his girlfriend and another man. What police initially treated as a violent robbery may instead have been a planned attack aimed at gaining access to his bank accounts.
The Organismo de Investigación Judicial (OIJ) arrested the suspects—identified by their surnames as Arroyo (31) and Gutiérrez (34)—during raids on three homes in Roxana, Pococí, Limón, on November 12.
Arroyo was Van Dyke’s girlfriend. Investigators are still seeking two other men they believe were involved.
Van Dyke, 66, was found dead on February 14 at his home in Hone Creek, near Puerto Viejo de Talamanca, in the Province of Limón. He had stab wounds and signs of strangulation.
Arroyo initially told police that two armed men had entered the home, restrained her, and stolen valuables and her car. The vehicle, a 2013 Hyundai Elantra, was later found undamaged. Investigators say that the discovery and inconsistencies in the account led them to question whether the robbery had been staged.
OIJ official Vladimir Muñoz told La Nación that Van Dyke had been tortured for his bank-card codes.
Read more: Suspect in Killing American in Playas del Coco Left Trail by Using His Credit Cards
Van Dyke was originally from Santa Cruz, California, and had lived in Costa Rica for decades. He ran a hotel in Puerto Viejo and was known in the local surf community as the “King of Salsa Brava,” after the Caribbean coast’s celebrated break.
Why the case changed direction. The reported discovery of Arroyo’s undamaged car gave investigators a reason to revisit the first account of a robbery.
The proposed financial motive also changes the central question: rather than asking only who entered the house and what they took, investigators must establish who planned the attack, who was present, and what evidence links each suspect to it.
Discover more from Q COSTA RICA
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

