Saturday 17 April 2021

Unacceptable to intervene journalist’s telehones in order to know their sources

The College of Journalists of Costa Rica and the Institute of Press and Freedom of Expression has flatly rejected the proposal by a Supreme Court judge to tap journalist's telephones to uncover leaks in the judiciary; Government reinforces commitment to freedom of the press

The College of Journalists of Costa Rica and the Institute of Press and Freedom of Expression (Iplex) described the suggestion made by Judge Iris Rocío Rojas Morales as unacceptable, that journalists’ telephones should be intervened for the judiciary to know their sources.

Supreme Court Iris Rocío Rojas said in Monday’s Full Court session, “The secret of the journalist’s source is not unlimited.” Photo: Rafael Pacheco / La Nacion

Raúl Silesky, president of Iplex, said: “we are concerned that a magistrate suggests actions against that fundamental right. It is unacceptable as it goes against the Constitutional Court (also known as Sala IV) vote of April 30, 2008, and of the international standards of freedom of the press. That would mean a serious setback for our democracy.”

- Advertisement -

Silesky also noted that the organization expresses its total opposition to Rojas’s proposal, while calling on the Judiciary to promote internal training processes for its magistrates, “in order to promote the strengthening of our fundamental freedoms” and not the opposite.

Meanwhile, Belisario Solano, president of the College of Journalists of Costa Rica, openly censored Judge Rojas’ proposal to intervene in the telephones of journalists.

“It is not possible for the Costa Rican press to suffer such an attack, much less coming from the Judiciary. I invite Judge Rojas to put aside that proposal and to ask the Court to investigate whether or not there is information leakage”.

In Solano’s opinion, the judge’s proposal could be taken “as a way of attacking freedom of the press, against the secrecy of the sources and against the right to information that Costa Rican society has. We censor such a proposal and ask the magistrates to stop any progress in that direction.”

- Advertisement -

Iris Rocío Rojas, a member of the Supreme Court, proposed in Full Court session the “possibility of” a reform so that journalists’ telephones and communications can be intervened in order to find out their sources within the Judiciary, in case of possible leaks”.

“The secrecy of the journalist’s source is not unlimited,” Rojas said in reference to the eventual leak of information from police operations that may fail to leak into the press.

On Tuesday, Iris Rocío Rojas clarified her comments on Monday, saying “…I am convinced it is necessary to investigate the internal leakage of information (in the Judiciary).” She also pointed out that her comments “do not represent the will of the Court”.

Tuesday afternoon, at the press conference at Casa Presidencial (Government House), the Minister of the Presidency, Víctor Morales Mora, also spoke against the magistrate’s suggestion.

“Of course we do not agree with an intervention on the phones of journalists. It seems to me that our commitment to press freedom should lead us to express ourselves against such initiatives,” he said.

In April 2008 and in March 2014, the Constitutional Court ruled on the issue of the intervention of journalist’s telephones in response to two recursos de amparo (appeals).

- Advertisement -

The first involved an individual who requested La Nación gave him a copy of the documents that supported the publication of an investigative report in 2007. The appeal was filed after the journalist refused to hand over the documents, citing it violated the right of journalists not to disclose their sources.

In March 2014, the magistrates received an appeal filed by journalist Manuel Estrada of the Diario Extra, who reported that the Organismo de Investigación Judicial (OIJ) and the  Ministerio Público (Prosecutor’s Office) had, without the authorization of a criminal judge, intervened his phone in order to know his source.

The magistrates considered that the evidence obtained by the judicial authorities was void.

- Advertisement -

FACT CHECK:
We strive for accuracy in its reports. But if you see something that doesn’t look right, send us an email. The Q reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it’s accuracy.

Ricohttp://www.theqmedia.com
"Rico" is the crazy mind behind the Q media websites, a series of online magazines where everything is Q! In these times of new normal, stay at home. Stay safe. Stay healthy.

Related Articles

MOST READ

Nicaragua to renew electoral tribunal, amid claims for impartiality

TODAY NICARAGUA – The Nicaraguan Legislative Assembly, controlled by the ruling party, is preparing to renew the electoral tribunal, amid requests from civil society...

RECOPE asks for another hike in fuel prices

QCOSTARICA - If you haven't gotten over the whopping increase in fuel prices that went into effect this Wednesday, ready for another, the fifth...

Tesla arrives in Costa Rica

QCOSTARICA - They are known for their electric propulsion system, but their characteristics go further. They have a leading autopilot in autonomous driving technology,...

Former Miss Costa Rica detained at San Jose airport on suspicion of false covid test

UPDATED April 17 QCOSTARICA - Model, television presenter and former Miss Costa Rica 2018, Natalia Carvajal Sánchez, was arrested this Friday, morning, April 16, at...

The Pandemic: Epidemiological report April 13, 2021

QCOSTARICA -  Costa Rica added 891 COVID-19 cases on Saturday, April 10, 482 on Sunday, April 11, 469 on Monday, April 12, and 957...

Editorial: A national joke

QCOSTARICA - Following is a translation of the editorial in La Nacion Friday following the report that the last 3 kilometers of the expansion...

Covid rebound: 435 people hospitalized, 208 in Intensive Care

QCOSTARICA - During a last-minute press conference from Casa Presidencial, the Minister of Health, Daniel Salas, did not rule out increased measures to stem...

Beginning of the week will be loaded with afternoon rains, says weather service

QCOSTARICA - Today, Monday, April 12, rains accompanied by a thunderstorm are expected during the afternoon, no different than the rains pouring down over...

Heredia Hospital enables vaccination to speed up campaign against covid-19

QCOSTARICA - The San Vicente de Paúl Hospital in Heredia, enabled a vaccination program in the mobile unit installed outside of the medical center...

WANT TO STAY UP TO DATE WITH THE LATEST!

Get our daily newsletter with the latest posts directly in your mailbox. Click on the subscribe and fill out the form. It's that simple!

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.