Wednesday, 8 July 2020

Bananas Putting Costa Rica’s Caimans at Risk Or Bad Science Journalism?

caimans-banana-plantations-costa-rica-main_72122_600x450
A spectacled caiman, Caiman crocodilus, sits partially submerged in water. Pesticides are threatening the Costa Rican caiman population. Photograph by John Cancalosi, National Geographic

For more than a week, news media outlets in Costa Rica and around the world have been publishing articles with eye-grabbing headlines that allude to the worldwide popularity of bananas (Musa acuminata et al) as being responsible for the demise of the Caiman crocodilus in our Caribbean coast.

Clever headlines such as “Yellow Peril,” “Crocs Going Bananas,” “Love For Bananas is Killing Caimans in Costa Rica” accentuate a problem that is not being interpreted correctly.

More than two dozen news outlets and science blogs have reported on a single press release about a research study published in the Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry journal. Even the Costa Rica Star jumped on the bandwagon of a story too interesting to resist. The basics of the story are well posited by the respected National Geographic News:

Costa Rica is a prime location for banana production. As a key export, bananas play an important role in the nation’s economy. In 2011, Costa Rica exported 2 million tons (1.9 million metric tons) of bananas, valued at over $700 million.

As demand for the fruit increases, so does pesticide use. In the last two decades, pesticide use in Central America has doubled. Costa Rica ranks second in the world for intensity of pesticide use […]

spectacled caimans (Caiman crocodilus) near banana plantations were significantly thinner, and had higher pesticide concentrations in their blood, than caimans in more remote locations.

- paying the bills -

In Costa Rica, one of the leading environmentalist news publications, El Pais, reported as follows:

Banana Pesticides Poison Caimans

Plague control methods used in banana plantations of Costa Rica are poisoning caimans; even those in protected areas (such as Tortuguero National Park) […]

According to El Pais, some of the contaminants found in caimans’ blood include DDT, which has been prohibited for decades but traces remain in the habitat and make their way into caimans’ tissues and organs, thereby making them sick. Then, El Pais goes on to put numbers to the sizable exports of bananas -about 107 million boxes, almost half of them sold to the people of the United States, who simply cannot get enough of this delicious and nutritious fruit.

A Sharp Journalist Looks at the Issue

Naturally, El Pais and other publications invite to point fingers at the irresponsible use of pesticides and unsustainable farming techniques. There is a problem with this uncritical reporting of science news. Enter Anne Vezina, a prominent science blogger at ProMusa, a site that chooses the tagline: “Mobilizing banana science for sustainable livelihoods.” Ms. Vezina explains what called her attention to the media blitz of bananas vs. caimans:

The first thing that caught my attention was the type of pesticides detected in the caimans: 7 organochlorine insecticides and 2 pyrethroid insecticides. Organochlorines are pesticides like DDT, banned chemicals that are known to persist in the environment and accumulate in the food chain. I had never come across them in relation to bananas, except for chlordecone, but it was not one of the 7. Moreover, while it’s true that the banana industry in Costa Rica is a heavy consumer of pesticides, the intensive spraying regimen for which it is known uses fungicides, not insecticides,

Ms. Vezina actually consulted the research paper, asked questions of the research authors and even went as far as to contact representatives from Dole and Chiquita in Costa Rica. Essentially, Ms. Vezina is using science and investigative journalism techniques that we should all be thankful for. It turns out that none of the pesticides mentioned in the study were used by Costa Rica’s banana industry back in 2006, when the caimans were sampled.

- paying the bills -

Another slight red flag raised by the study and the ensuing media coverage thereof was the focus of the researchers on bananas. Ms. Vezina found that it was the researchers’ understanding that agriculture in Tortuguero is limited to the banana cash crop; she knows this is not true, and any Tico or visitor to the area knows this as well. Cultivation of other crops, both organic and massively farmed, takes place in the area, and some farmers might use pesticides and fungicides.

What follows is the most important portion of Ms. Vezina’s findings:

I am aware that by speaking out against this study I risk coming across as an apologist for monocultures and heavy pesticide use. I am not. I did this post mainly to underscore the importance of basing recommendations on solid scientific evidence.

That is not to say that there is nothing the banana industry can do to reduce pesticides in plantations.

[…] there could be a way to grow pesticide-free bananas for export in the humid tropics, except that most consumers don’t want to hear about it. But that’s another post.

We hope that Ms. Vezina and other sharp observers and journalists decide to take a critical look at such issues in the future. Their work is refreshing in this era of catchy headlines and uncritical reporting.

Article by Costa Rica Star

Carter Maddox
Carter Maddoxhttp://cjmaddox.com
Carter is self-described as thirty-three-and-a-half years old and his thirty-three-and-a-half years birthday is always on March 3. Carter characteristically avoids pronouns, referring to himself in the third person (e.g. "Carter has a question" rather than, "I have a question"). One day [in 1984], Carter, raised himself up and from that day forward we could all read what Carter writes.

Related Articles

Cuba Plane Crash: Company ‘Had Safety Complaints’

Solidarity and investigations after the accident. Cuban authorities are investigating the...

The Volcanos Of Central America (By Country)

Among the things most loved by travelers to Central America is...

MOST READ

With lower cost for business, Costa Rica will enjoy 16 long weekends

(QCOSTARICA) The bill that transfers the holidays for the following or previous Monday, with the aim of promoting local tourism, economic recovery, and job...

Road paving in Costa Rica

Auditor's report: road asphalt deteriorates in 90 days of paving.

Death 22 confirmed; Second death today Monday

(QCOSTARICA) The Ministry of Health confirmed this Monday morning death number 22 by COVID-19. This is another post-mortem COVID-19 death, that of a 51-year-old man,...

Coronavirus: US facing ‘big problem’ as COVID-19 cases surge

(Q REPORTS) The United States appeared on track to set a new daily record for COVID-19 cases on Thursday, with several southern and western...

Is entry into the European Union based on physical location or nationality?

(QCOSTARICA) On July 1 the European Union (EU) Member States approved a list of 15 countries, considered as 'safe' due to their epidemiological situation...

Death 21 by COVID-19 in Costa Rica confirmed

(QCOSTARICA) The Ministry of Health, this Monday morning, July 6, confirmed death number 21 in the country, by COVID-19. The deceased was an 81-year-old man,...

Let's Keep This Going!

To be updated with all the latest news and information about Costa Rica and Latin America.