Saturday, 31 October 2020

Why Are The U.S. and Russia Clashing Over Venezuela?

Washington Post – There was an unexpected twist Tuesday evening as Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaidó’s attempted uprising against President Nicolás Maduro’s government appeared to be sputtering out. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said that Maduro was set to flee Venezuela — but that Russia had persuaded him to stay.

Russian President Vladimir Putin meets with his Venezuelan counterpart, Nicolás Maduro, outside Moscow on Dec. 5, 2018. Photo Maxim Shemetov/Reuters

Russia denies the claim, and on Wednesday, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said in a phone call with Pompeo that Washington’s “interference” was “a most grave violation of international law,” according to Russia’s Foreign Ministry. “It was indicated that continuing these aggressive steps would be fraught with the most serious consequences,” a Foreign Ministry statement describing the call said. “Only the Venezuelan people have the right to determine their own fate, which is why a dialogue is necessary between all the political forces of the whole country, as its government has long been calling for.”

“They had an airplane on the tarmac. He was ready to leave this morning, as we understand it. Russians indicated he should stay,” Pompeo said in an interview with CNN.

The anecdote underscored the battle for influence being waged between the United States, which firmly backs Guaidó, and Russia, a friend of the Maduro government, over Venezuela.

- Advertisement -

But why does the Kremlin care what happens in Caracas? Below, a primer on why Moscow, like Washington, has been open about what it wants to see happen next in Venezuela.

Is this about money?

Yes, but not only. As The Washington Post reported late last year, Russia owns substantial portions of Venezuelan oil fields, which it got in exchange for loans and bailouts over the past decade. And Venezuela signed over almost half of Citgo — its wholly owned company in the United States — as collateral to Rosneft, Russia’s state-owned oil company, for what was reported to be $1.5 billion in cash.

And “with something in the neighborhood of US$20 billion in Rosneft assets tied up in the country, the Russians have real concerns they could lose out as a result of a wholesale change in power — despite assurances from the opposition and the U.S. that would not be the case,” Matthew Rojansky, director of the Wilson Center’s Russia-focused Kennan Institute, wrote in an email.

- Advertisement -

Prepaid oil deliveries to Russian clients were also used to buy Russian tanks and guns for Venezuela’s defense force.

Some have argued that the loans, because they were not approved by the opposition-controlled National Assembly, “would not be legal under Venezuelan rule of law,” as Moises Rendon, associate director and associate fellow of the Center for Strategic and International Studies Americas Program, told The Post.

“They want to remain in Venezuela not only today, but for a day after,” said Rendon, a former legal analyst with Banco Occidental de Descuento, a prominent Venezuelan commercial bank, referring to Russian interests. “They want to be sure they get their money and their investments are protected.”

Okay, so it’s about money and energy and the military?

Well, and Cuba.


- Advertisement -

Part of the reason that the Trump administration and its supporters in Congress feel as strongly as they do about Venezuela is because of opposition to communist Cuba, which backs Venezuela.

But if U.S. opposition to Maduro is an extension of U.S. opposition to Cuba, then is it, in a way, history repeating itself? When the Trump administration reversed President Barack Obama’s thawing of relations with Havana, Cuba went back to tightening ties with Cold War ally Russia. Among the economic and political clashes that defined the Cold War, perhaps the most famous was the Cuban missile crisis in the 1960s, when the Soviet Union put nuclear-armed missiles on Cuba, a flex of force not far from U.S. shores. President John F. Kennedy and Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev ultimately defused the crisis.

But such a reading of historical parallels to the Venezuela crisis is too neat and ignores that this is not the 1960s. As Rendon noted, Russia has not put nuclear-armed missiles in Venezuela. And the world is not divided between the United States and the Soviet Union. “Having a broader coalition is probably more effective,” Rendon said, suggesting that the United States should call on Brazil, Colombia, Argentina and Peru to effectively ask Russia to step back.

And there are other countries that are just as, if not more, relevant to Russia’s involvement in Venezuela.

What are they?

Well, Libya and Syria.

Libya and Syria?

“The Syrian and Libyan models are more important here than the 60-year-old Cuban case,” Rojansky wrote.

In 2011, a coalition led by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization helped rebels oust Libyan leader Moammar Gaddafi, who was killed shortly thereafter. “The Libyan case represents exactly what Russia fears most — that if it does nothing, America will use military power to topple a Moscow-friendly regime,” Rojansky wrote.

That fear is not just about what happened in Libya. “Official Moscow is utterly preoccupied with the notion that Washington uses its power to force favorable regime changes around the world, and that sooner or later Russia itself will be on the target list. The Russians therefore oppose any change in the Maduro regime both because America so strongly supports it, and because of the unacceptable precedent such change might set for Russia itself and for other states closer to home in Eurasia,” he wrote.

The Libya case, the thinking goes, is part of why the Russian powers that have been so supportive of Syria’s Bashar al-Assad. And just as Russia learned from Libya that the West could not be left to intervene in a country without its leader ending up dead, so, too, did Russia learn something from Syria.

“The Syrian model suggests that with a relatively small military commitment and some agile diplomacy, Moscow can not only prevent this outcome but secure enormous enduring leverage over the local government,” Rojansky wrote.

Russia, in all likelihood, can’t fight in Venezuela as it has in Syria. Venezuela is half a world away, and Russia is preoccupied elsewhere. “But at relatively low cost, they can put down markers that will strengthen their negotiating position both with Washington and internally with the Venezuelan parties, like sending a high ranking general and a few plane loads of troops and supplies,” Rojansky wrote.

So it’s about money and energy and the military and kind of Cuba and Libya and Syria?

Well, and Russia’s own neighbors.

Russia cares about Venezuela because of its own neighbors?

Yes. “Most immediately, getting involved in Venezuela gives [Russian President Vladimir] Putin the opportunity to poke the U.S. in the eye,” wrote Andrea Kendall-Taylor, senior fellow and director of the Transatlantic Security Program at the Center for a New American Security.

“From Putin’s perspective, inserting himself in Washington’s backyard is payback for U.S. meddling near Russia’s borders,” an allusion to the expansion of NATO, Russian perception of U.S. support for revolutions in the former Soviet republics of Georgia and Ukraine, and any number of other real and imagined instances of U.S. meddling.

Article originally appeared on Today Venezuela and is republished here with permission.

- Advertisement -
Q24N is an aggregator of news for Latin America. Reports from Mexico to the tip of Chile and Caribbean are sourced for our readers to find all their Latin America news in one place.

Related Articles

#DEBUNKED: False tweet circulates in which Donald Trump relates Carlos Alvarado to Nicolás Maduro

#DEBUNKED: NOT TRUE that the president of the United States, Donald...

How many currencies does Cuba need?

Havana residents last week welcomed the ending of a month-long coronavirus...


COVID-19 in Costa Rica: 1,372 new cases and 30 deaths for Sunday and Monday

QCOSTARICA - The report Monday by the Ministry of Health detailed 1,372 new cases for 48 hours from Saturday to Monday, for a total...

Agreement between legislators: marchamo would drop only for vehicles of less than ¢15 million

QCOSTARICA - Legislators from different political parties reached an agreement on Monday, October 26, to reduce the property tax portion of the 2021 Marchamo,...

La Niña is back and will bring storms, drought and bad weather

QCOSTARICA - The La Niña climate phenomenon has developed and is expected to last into next year, affecting temperatures, precipitation and storm patterns in...

Distrust of sectors complicate signing an agreement with the IMF this year

QCOSTARICA - Reaching a structural adjustment agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) this year seems like an impossible mission for President Carlos Alvarado,...

Vatican awaits debate on secular state before granting legislator audience with the Pope

QCOSTARICA - The Vatican will wait for the Legislative Assembly to begin the discussion of the secular state before giving Costa Rica legislators an...

COVID-19 in Costa Rica: 1,296 new cases; country reinforces shelters for risk of floods due to tropical depression

QCOSTARICA - The General Director of Health, Priscilla Herrera, confirmed 1,296 new cases of COVID-19 for Friday, October 30, of which 275 are by...

Let's Keep This Going!

To be updated with all the latest news and information about Costa Rica and Latin America.

Article originally appeared on Today Venezuela and is republished here with permission.

Log In

Forgot password?

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.